Tax & Social Security Italy draws the line on unemployment benefit after workplace transfers Distance alone is not enough to make a resignation one for just cause, Supreme Court rules, placing the focus on whether the employer’s transfer was lawful iStock.com/fab4istock Image Elisa Mapelli Monday 02 November 2026 In Italy, an employer may change an employee’s place of work in the exercise of its managerial and organisational powers. When the transfer requires relocation far from home, a social security question arises: is an employee who resigns, rather than accept it, entitled to Italy’s unemployment benefit, Nuova Assicurazione Sociale per l'Impiego (NASpI)?In Order No. 10559 of 21 April 2026, the Italian Supreme Court held that distance alone is not enough. The outcome is consistent with the underlying case, but the principle articulated has broader scope and, read together with Order No. 8564 of 6 April 2026, raises several issues.The relevant provisions are Article 3 of Legislative Decree No. 22/2015 (involuntary unemployment) as well as Articles 2119 (just cause) and 2103 (transfers) of the Italian Civil Code.Involuntary unemployment and resignation for just causeArticle 3 of Legislative Decree No. 22/2015 grants NASpI to those who have involuntarily lost their employment and, under paragraph 2, to those who have resigned for just cause. The legislature thus adopted Italian Constitutional Court Judgment No. 269/2002: such resignations are not a free choice but result from a defect in the relationship so serious that it prevents its continuation.The resigning employee must therefore prove just cause, that is, that the termination resulted from conduct by the employer that was serious, or at least objectively intolerable.Article 2103 of the Italian Civil Code permits transfers only for “proven technical, organisational, and production-related reasons”. Courts verify that such reasons genuinely exist, without reviewing the merits of the business decision (Supreme Court, Judgment No. 25384/2015); in their absence, the transfer constitutes a contractual breach.The case and principle of lawThe case involved an employee living in Genoa who was transferred to Catania and then resigned. Reversing the first-instance decision, the Genoa Court of Appeal found just cause, holding that a transfer of well over 50 kilometres, with the practical impossibility of working at such a distance, constituted a serious objective circumstance, regardless of any breach by the employer.The Supreme Court upheld the appeal brought by the Italian National Social Security Institute (INPS): by focusing solely on distance, the appeal court failed to determine whether the transfer was supported by technical, organisational, and production-related reasons, the absence of which alone would have constituted just cause. Citing Judgment No. 23039/2024, the Supreme Court reaffirmed that NASpI is excluded when an employee voluntarily relinquishes employment that could have continued.The principle of law stated is as follows: NASpI following resignation requires circumstances attributable to the employer that amount to a serious breach or conduct making continuation of the relationship, even temporarily, intolerable; the significant distance resulting from the transfer is not, in itself, sufficient.The judgment was therefore quashed and remanded to the Genoa Court of Appeal.The burden of proof and relationship with administrative practiceThe order No. 10559 of 21 April 2026 significantly increases the evidentiary burden on employees, who cannot merely prove the transfer and the distance involved but must demonstrate that the transfer was unlawful under Article 2103 of the Italian Civil Code, for example due to the absence of proven business reasons or the retaliatory or abnormal nature of the transfer. Distance and logistical hardship remain relevant but are not independently sufficient. Under settled case law, employees must also demonstrate that the resignation followed promptly upon the employer’s conduct.The decision better specifies the INPS practice. Circular No. 94/2015 treated as just cause any transfer lacking “proven reasons”, regardless of distance, and recognised involuntary unemployment in the case of mutual termination following refusal of a transfer of more than 50 kilometres or more than 80 minutes by public transport.Divergent views in legal scholarshipAccording to a first school of thought, the order curbs an overly expansive application of just cause for social security purposes, preventing NASpI from becoming a benefit linked solely to geographical distance and protecting the freedom of enterprise guaranteed by Article 41 of the Italian Constitution.A second, more critical school of thought argues that the decision conflates civil law just cause with social security involuntary unemployment, and that greater weight should be given to personal circumstances (family responsibilities, inability to relocate, disproportionate costs), treating circulars as useful, albeit non-binding, benchmarks and preventing social security litigation from becoming a more burdensome “second trial”.Lawful does not necessarily mean voluntaryThe order raises a question that goes beyond the distance between Genoa and Catania: when is a choice truly free? For the Supreme Court, if the employer’s organisational power was lawfully exercised, the employee could have kept the job, and the resignation is voluntary.The reasoning is legally coherent, but reality is often more complex. An employee with a mortgage, school-age children, or elderly relatives to care for may not have two equally viable alternatives, but only one realistic choice, even if it means the termination of employment. Describing it as “voluntary” is technically accurate but does not fully capture the employee’s lived reality. Social security law must, however, draw a line: too broad, it would turn NASpI into a benefit available for any personal reason; too narrow, it would shift onto employees the costs of employers’ organisational decisions. Denying distance a decisive role is a defensible choice, but it does not resolve the question of where the right balance lies.There are also practical implications: a distant transfer could become a way to encourage an employee’s departure without dismissal. And a paradox remains: the same circumstances may entitle an employee to NASpI in the case of mutual termination, but not in the case of resignation.Perhaps the main lesson is not about distance: the manner in which the relationship ends can matter as much as the reasons it ends, and understanding this before making a decision is essential.Practical guidanceThe order provides a clear message: distance alone does not make unemployment involuntary. Entitlement to NASpI requires a judicial assessment of the lawfulness of the transfer.For employers, it is essential to carefully document the technical, organisational, and production-related reasons for every transfer: A lawful transfer does not constitute a contractual breach.For employees and their advisers, distance is not enough: before resigning, they should assess and, where appropriate, challenge the reasons for the transfer, and gather evidence of its unlawfulness. Otherwise, the resignation will be regarded as voluntary and will not entitle the employee to NASpI.In such cases, the parties may consider a mutual termination agreement, which – however, unlike resignation for just cause – does not entitle the employee to notice or the related indemnity in lieu of notice. Unlike ordinary mutual terminations, here it appears to preserve entitlement to NASpI if the new workplace is more than 50 kilometres away and can be reached by public transport in more than 80 minutes.Contributing to this article are trainees Francesco Cannavina and Rachele Miotello. You might also like... Contracts Why employers must align contract terms with real working arrangements Disputes New unfair dismissal protections for small business employees in Italy Artificial Intelligence AI, deepfakes, and digital evidence: Lessons from Italy’s courts Pay transparency Pay Transparency Directive: Italy implements it on time, but not without caveats