Pushing the boundaries of employment law

Head of legal services at Unison, Shantha David, explains why trade-union lawyers are not “Cinderella-types” and how good communication is key to avoiding disputes

Shantha David
Shantha David, Unison

Not all in-house legal teams are created equal. Indeed, there are practice heads at major law firms who would kill to have a scorecard of cutting-edge disputes like Shantha David’s, head of legal at Unison. For the last 20 years, David has been fighting for the rights of her union’s more than 1 million members, and taking plenty of big-name scalps along the way – including the UK government’s in a landmark decision before the Supreme Court over access to justice.

Born in Malaysia to Sri Lankan parents, David travelled the world from an early age by virtue of her father’s job as a diplomat and ambassador. Egypt, India, Sri Lanka, Germany, and Bangladesh were her playgrounds before settling in the UK where she completed her A-Levels and a degree in history and politics at the University of London in 1995, followed by a law conversion course in 1997. A three-month internship in the United Nation’s legal department in New York found her working with the team establishing the International Criminal Court, further whetting her appetite for a career in law. Returning to London in 1999, she undertook a master’s in intellectual property law while working as a paralegal in the entertainment firm Theodore Goddard (“a great place to work in the late ’90s,” she says).

When that role came to an end, David tried her hand at legal journalism, spending a year at Legalease – publisher of Legal Business, In-House Lawyer, and the Legal 500. “I was interviewing law firms and figuring out where I would never work,” she laughs. “There were some terrible places out there, but I realised that I really wanted to practice law.” Unsure of what that practice might look like, David obtained a Middle Temple scholarship to BPP Law School with the aim of qualifying as a barrister. Prior to that, she had worked as a paralegal in Freshfields Bruckhaus Deringer’s corporate team (“You didn’t get a lot of hands-on experience very quickly and it was very hierarchical, in my experience,” she recalls).

With her experience of the UN and two leading law firms – not to mention inside market knowledge gleaned from countless directory interviews – one might have expected David to walk into another elite City outfit, or to put her IP knowledge to good use within the ranks of a leading boutique or international outfit. Instead, she took another paralegal role, this time at Unison, Europe’s largest public service union, and cross-qualified as a solicitor. “It started as a temporary job, but then I managed to stay a really long time, which often happens at Unison. The difference between working in a place like Freshfields and working for a small in-house team is that, within a very short period of time, I was running my own cases to the Employment Appeal Tribunal; I also assisted on a House of Lords case. It was a very different environment and it felt quite rewarding.”

We do the difficult cases. That’s the reality of working at Unison. It’s not the sort of place where you wait to be served up a case. You make the case

For an organisation representing 1.3 million members, describing Unison’s award-winning in-house team as “small” is a bit of an understatement. While the more run-of-the-mill labour and workplace injury claims are handled by external trade union specialists Thompson Solicitors, Unison’s six lawyers – one of whom is based in Scotland – along with two paralegals and five non-legal staff retain ownership of more strategic litigation.

In the past 12 months alone, that has included forcing the government to abandon its redundancy cap of £95,000 for senior public servants; winning back £124m in miscalculated holiday pay for NHS staff; supporting Fiona Mercer in closing a legal loophole allowing employers to discipline workers engaged in union-organised disputes (decision is currently being challenged before the Court of Appeal); and securing £27m in personal injury settlements across more than 2,100 claims.

Last year’s results were far from an outlier for this agenda-setting team. In 2019, Unison intervened in Harpur Trust v Brazel where the Court of Appeal held all workers are entitled to a minimum of 28 days paid annual leave, even if they work part-time or have irregular hours or patterns (decision currently on appeal to the Supreme Court). That same year, Unison secured another Court of Appeal victory, this time for NHS workers who regularly work overtime. The decision in Flowers and others vs East of England Ambulance Trust means extra hours must now be taken into account when holiday pay is calculated.

A year earlier, Unison secured a £5m settlement from a local authority that had miscalculated the holiday pay of 500 school staff over a five-year period. And, in 2017, the Supreme Court’s Lock v British Gas decision found that workers whose wages include an element of commission cannot be paid less when on annual leave. All these decisions have benefited tens of thousands of mostly low-paid workers, however, it was Unison’s landmark demolition over employment tribunal fees in 2017 that remains David’s proudest achievement to date as it guaranteed access to justice for all employees.

Paying for justice

In 2013, the UK’s then coalition government announced the introduction of fees to access the employment tribunal system. The controversial move was designed to free tribunals from allegedly groundless litigation that cost businesses time and money to defend, while simultaneously pushing workers and employers towards mediating meritorious claims out of court. However, many pointed to the hefty budget cuts faced by the Ministry of Justice as the real reason the then Lord Chancellor, Chris Grayling, wanted to introduce his fee-paying system.

With fees to bring an action starting at between £160 and £250, depending on the type of claim, plus further hearing fees of between £230 and £950, critics argued that forcing such costs on low-income workers would effectively deny the public access to justice. These arguments fell on deaf ears, however, and tribunal fees were introduced in July 2013.

Running Unison’s judicial review challenge, David saw the High Court dismiss the union’s initial arguments in July 2014, with the judge describing them as “premature” and concluding there was not enough evidence to support the assertion that the fees regime was stopping workers from bringing claims. “Right from the start, I knew it was uncharted territory. At the beginning, we had no evidence. We knew fees were a bad thing, but what we didn’t know was how it was all going to pan out. I had to find the evidence” explains David.

A month later the full impact of the fees regime began to become clearer. A response to a Freedom of Information request, filed by David, showed the number of claims for July to September 2013 fell by 56% on the previous year; claims plummeted by 79% in the final quarter of 2013 – a figure that stayed roughly consistent as the government continued to publish quarterly statistics.

Armed with this new evidence, David launched a second judicial review only for the High Court to once again dismiss the challenge. A visit to the Court of Appeal followed but judges ruled that a drop in the number of claims was not enough to prove claimants were unable to afford fees. Despite losing a total of six hearings – three in the High Court and three in the Court of Appeal – David doggedly fought on knowing that her best chance was before the UK’s highest court.

Unison’s four-year legal battle eventually reached the Supreme Court where, on 26 July 2017, justices dealt the government a devastating blow by unanimously finding the fees were “inconsistent with access to justice” and contrary to the Equality Act 2010; with a higher proportion of women bringing discrimination claims, fees were found to be indirectly discriminatory. In addition to scrapping tribunal fees, the court also ordered the government to repay £32m to claimants who had already paid the fees of up to £1,200. “We do the difficult cases. That’s the reality of working at Unison. It’s not the sort of place where you wait to be served up a case. You make the case,” says David.

Image
Unison Legal
The Unison legal team outside the UK Supreme Court in 2017. Justices unanimously held that the government's tribunal fee system was set too high and “had a deterrent effect upon discrimination claims, among others”.

Unison’s work challenging the fees regime led to a host of legal awards for the in-house team. It won The Lawyer’s best employment team award in 2014 just for bringing the claim against the government. Two years later, and fresh from another bruising Court of Appeal encounter, the team was presented with the Solicitor’s Journal’s annual employment team gong. Then, in 2018, with the Supreme Court’s judgment still ringing in their ears, victory in The Lawyer’s litigation team of the year category. And then there was the personal recognition. David was named human rights lawyer of 2018 by civil rights campaign group Liberty; won the Lexis Nexis Halsbury Rule of Law award the same year; and she appeared in The Lawyer’s Hot 100 list for 2020.

“I had someone come up to me at an event saying, ‘Oh, gosh. You’re on that fees case. Sorry to hear you keep losing. Is that the only thing you’re working on?’ At the time I laughed and said that I wish it was, but that’s not how we work. At that point, I was doing the Lock case in the European Court of Justice and some big multi-claimant cases, too, so it wasn’t a quiet time,” recalls David. “The fees case was a challenge on several fronts, not least the fact that we were pushed back on several occasions, but we knew our best shot was to be in the Supreme Court anyway. It was such a good day. It took a while for it to sink in because it meant so much to so many, and the judgment was a work of beauty.”

The ruling is so well-crafted, David believes it may be key to undermining the UK government’s plans to reform judicial review. “Unlike Acts of Parliament, which go through the full parliamentary scrutiny, secondary legislation doesn’t go through the same rigorous process. The government’s current consultation on human rights seeks to limit the ability of judicial reviews to challenge breaches on statutory instruments that are not European Convention on Human Rights compliant. If that goes through, it’ll be even harder to challenge unlawful decisions of the government. Certainly, that becomes a question of access to justice.”

Lingering impact

While employment claims have been on the rise since 2017, the long-term effects of the fees regime continue to be felt by Unison’s legal team. David, who is currently chair of the Law Society’s specialist employment law committee, notes that a 70% drop in disputes between 2013 and 2017 made employment law a loss-making enterprise for claimant firms and an unattractive proposition for many aspiring solicitors. “Employment lawyers have been few and far between. I am recruiting at the moment and it’s hard to find many lawyers because we have this four-year gap. Those at the four-to-six-year-qualified level don’t really exist,” she says.

As someone who spent her early days within the City elite, would David consider a candidate from the magic circle or a leading employer-side practice? In short, yes, but it would depend upon the candidate. “A lot of these firms have very hierarchical systems where people do not think outside the box. By the time they’re in a position that allows individuals to use their own minds, they’ve forgotten how to do it. Perhaps that is harsh, and that doesn’t apply to everyone, of course, as there are some very bright and clever people in the City. However, I feel their drive for excellence, and attention to detail, sometimes gets knocked out of them when they do very formulaic roles.”

David is keen to avoid any perception that trade-union lawyers are “Cinderella-types” or that no one would trade the ivory towers of private practice to work for a union. “The world’s changed and young people, especially, want to feel value in the work they do; it’s not just about making money. If someone’s objective is to make as much money as they can, then I wouldn’t expect them to want to work for us. But if they want to push the boundaries of employment law, then they might. I feel joy in making someone’s life a bit better. There’s a lot in knowing you’re making a difference. It’s not that I am interested in bleeding hearts – I want people to work hard and do a good job.”

Covid trends

As IEL has highlighted this past year, the covid-19 pandemic has been the key issue dominating the collective attention of employment lawyers worldwide. In the UK, many covid-related employment claims are only just reaching a first-hearing stage. According to the Ministry of Justice, the current waiting time from receipt of a claim to a first hearing is currently 335 days for single claims, and 388 days for multiple claims. This backlog means we have yet to see any key pandemic-related trends or landmark decisions. But David believes they are coming.

“Cases are being listed a year from now, so we’re not going to see covid claims for a little while yet. There’s still high volumes of disability discrimination claims from stress to physical disabilities. We are seeing an increase in race claims. What we’re not seeing are maternity or pregnancy discrimination claims, which we know are there but women are reluctant to bring them.”

Disputes over data protection and worker surveillance in the post-covid world are other trends David expects to take off in the near future. She also imagines more whistleblowing claims will soon come to the fore and, while she has yet to see too many claims of biased algorithmic decision-making, she thinks these too will soon be on the horizon. “Those cases are there and they’re going to be considerable, but there is a lag. We could certainly do with more resources in the tribunals to help shift that lag.”

Sticking with the subject of AI, she adds: “I do feel quite strongly about how we, as lawyers, utilise AI to deliver a better service for clients. That’s partly because I don’t feel current case management systems are up to scratch. Those who can manipulate IT best will do a much better job for their clients. It would be much more cost-effective if we could utilise AI in terms of correspondence and processes. I know people are trying, but I don’t think it’s quite there yet.”

UK trade union membership has increased for the fourth year in a row, with official figures showing a rise of 118,000 during the heights of the covid pandemic in 2020. Data from the Department of Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy shows that while there was a “significant fall” of 110,000 among private-sector workers, there were 228,000 new trade unionists in the public sector. Overall, 6.6 million UK workers are now union members – 4 million in the public sector.

While this figure is still less than half the number of card-carrying trade unionists in 1979 – the height of the movement and year Margaret Thatcher became prime minister – does David think the covid pandemic might lead to an even greater resurgence in union membership? “At the beginning of the pandemic, there was all this talk about redundancies and precarious jobs. So, yes, we did see a rise because people wanted to feel protected and were comfortable seeking out a collective voice to represent them when they feel they’re alone.”

Finally, asked how employers can best avoid workplace disputes, especially among unionised workforces, David points to the importance of internal communication. “What we tend to see in organisations going through rounds of redundancies and outsourcing, is that problems occur when there aren’t good HR functions and people who know what they’re doing or have a good grasp of communication. A lack of communication is often why these matters end up in court.”