Smart glasses spark privacy and harassment fears in French workplaces

A wave of complaints is prompting French authorities to consider whether wearable cameras belong

Smart glasses
iStock.com/Ekkasit919

French authorities are investigating rising reports on the alleged nefarious use of smart glasses in the workplace as employers begin to question allowing the increasingly popular tech within the workplace. 

France’s data protection watchdog, the Commission Nationale de l'Informatique et des Libertés (CNIL), has received at least ten complaints of so-called “perv glasses” as employers seek guidance on whether they can ban the smart tech from company premises, according to a Reuters report. 

The Paris public prosecutor has also opened at least one criminal probe into sexual harassment complaints related to individuals using smart glasses to film women on the street without their consent. 

Smart glasses look like ordinary eyewear but contain cameras, microphones, and an AI assistant. They can be used to make calls, listen to music, and capture pictures and videos.

However, a recent spate of reports on “pick-up artists” surreptitiously recording women on the street as they harass them and later uploading the footage has led many to ring the alarm over the insidious harm the glasses can cause. 

Meta’s model, made in collaboration with luxury eyewear company EssilorLuxottica and its Ray-Ban and Oakley brands, is currently the most popular, holding a 76% share of the market and selling 7 million pairs last year. 

EssilorLuxottica did not reply to IEL’s request for comment prior to publication.

In a statement, Meta said: “We take misuse of our glasses seriously and cooperate with authorities where we can help. We don’t tolerate content that encourages harassment when it’s shared on our platforms and we remove this content when we detect it. 

“Our glasses are also built with privacy in mind, with a light that tells others when someone is recording which can't be turned off, and the camera won’t work if it’s covered or damaged.”

While Meta’s smart glasses contain small LED lights to indicate when someone is recording, some wearers have reportedly found workarounds to the safeguarding measure.

In June, CNIL called for greater vigilance on the privacy and ethical risks around smart glasses, which it said, “go beyond the CNIL’s power alone”. It warned against both the proliferation and trivialisation of surveillance in all public and private spaces.

The CNIL emphasised the right to privacy under France’s civil code, with instances of recording someone in a private establishment, including workplace, without their consent carrying a possible fine of up to €45,000 (£38,589) and a year’s imprisonment. 

CNIL also published the results of a survey asking French respondents their views on the smart tech. While most respondents (76%) saw them as a potential aid for people with a disability, like a hearing or visual impairment, nearly as many (67%) said they were a privacy risk. 

Throughout the survey’s responses, smart glasses consistently appealed more to men aged 25 to 49, with all respondents who did want a pair saying real-time translation (93%), GPS navigation (92%), and taking photos or videos (91%) were the glasses most attractive features. 

The investigations in France come as many employers wrestle with balancing the support such wearable tech offers disabled employees and the harassment risks associated with the ability to record someone without their knowledge. 

The Australian government announced on Thursday it was considering a “world-leading” ban on smart glasses in public workplaces. 

“Smart glasses can raise legitimate privacy and security concerns, particularly because of their ability to record and capture information,” said Public Service Minister Katy Gallagher.

Courts in England and Wales banned Meta glasses last month, stating that anyone trying to enter a court building wearing a pair would have them confiscated. The New York state court system has a similar ban in place.