Workplace Investigations

The starting position is that there is no general right for an employer to search an employee’s possessions. However, an employer may be able to undertake a search in circumstances where:

• the employee consents to the search;
• there is a “right to search” contained in a contract, policy, procedure or industrial instrument; or
• the request to search constitutes a lawful and reasonable direction.

If an employee agrees to a search of their possessions, this consent should be confirmed in writing. If the employee does not consent then the employer can issue a direction to the employee. If the direction is lawful and reasonable, and the employee does not comply, then disciplinary action may be considered.

The basic rule is that the employer may not search private data during internal investigations.

If there is a strong suspicion of criminal conduct on the part of the employee and a sufficiently strong justification exists, a search of private data may be justified.[1] The factual connection with the employment relationship is given, for example, in the case of a criminal act committed during working hours or using workplace infrastructure.[2]

Managing the outcome of the investigation is an important part of the process. The respondent must be informed of the outcome of the investigation as soon as possible after the investigation is completed and the decision-maker has decided how to proceed.

The investigator must decide whether the claims have been substantiated on the balance of probabilities and the decision-maker must decide what disciplinary action, if any, will be taken. Any disciplinary action should be proportionate to the seriousness of the misconduct. Disciplinary action could include a warning, counselling, monitoring of behaviour or termination of employment.

Ideally, the outcome of the investigation should be communicated to the respondent and complainant in writing, setting out the allegations that have been substantiated, unsubstantiated or whether there is insufficient evidence to make a finding.

Workplace investigations often result in an investigation report that is intended to serve as the basis for any measures to be taken by the company's decisionmakers.

The employee's right to information based on article 8, Swiss Federal Act on Data Protection also covers the investigation report, provided that the report and the data contained therein relate to the employee.[1] In principle, the employee concerned is entitled to receive a written copy of the entire investigation report free of charge (article 8 paragraph 5, Swiss Federal Act on Data Protection and article 1 et seq, Ordinance to the Federal Act on Data Protection). Redactions may be made where the interests of the company or third parties so require, but they are the exception and must be kept to a minimum.[2]